Camera Comparison: Xiaomi Mi A1 vs Moto G5 Plus vs Moto G5S Plus

By Prasid Banerjee | Published on 23 Nov 2017
Camera Comparison: Xiaomi Mi A1 vs Moto G5 Plus vs Moto G5S Plus
HIGHLIGHTS

The Moto G5 Plus has a single sensor, but its camera can go toe to toe with the best in its range. So, why not pit the three top budget phones against each other today?

The Xiaomi Mi A1(₹ 12400 at flipkart) (review), Moto G5 Plus (review) and Moto G5S Plus(₹ 11199 at flipkart) (review) are three of the most talked about budget smartphones this year. All three devices sport stock Android software, run the same hardware and advertise their “best in class” cameras. But there can only be one best in class, right? We set out to find out which phone should take that title.

In an earlier comparison between the Mi A1 and Moto G5S Plus, we found that the Mi device had a better camera than Moto’s dual-camera performer. But while dual cameras are a rave nowadays, the Moto G5 Plus can take all of them on with its dual-pixel camera. In fact, that’s the question we usually get. Which phones has a better camera? And here’s the answer.

Note: Images have been cropped and placed side-by-side for easier comparison. You can find original samples in the galleries embedded at the end of the story.

Sample 1:

When shooting in daylight, the three phones are able performers. But side by side comparison reveals the differences quite easily. Here, the Xiaomi Mi A1 produces a dull image, while the Moto G5S Plus produces a very warm photo. On the other hand, the Moto G5 Plus is the closest to source here, which is what a camera should be. However, the three remain comparable in terms of sharpness and details.

Left to right: Xiaomi Mi A1, Moto G5 Plus, Moto G5S Plus

Sample 2:

In this indoor shot, the Moto G5 Plus again produces the best white balance, though the Mi A1 is much closer this time. Both these phones also produce ample details, which is where the Moto G5S falters by a bit. Motorola’s dual-camera smartphone produces a softer image, losing some of the details, though we must say that the difference here is evident on side-by-side comparison only.

Top to bottom: Xiaomi Mi A1, Moto G5 Plus, Moto G5S Plus

Sample 3:

In this well lit shot taken indoors, but in natural light, the three cameras are basically at par. Both the Mi A1 and Moto G5S Plus produce a slightly softer photo, but we don’t think anyone would complain here. In fact, the shade of red looks better on the Moto G5 Plus, but you can call this one a tie.

Top to bottom: Xiaomi Mi A1, Moto G5 Plus and Moto G5S Plus

Sample 4:

Here, the scene is decently lit, but it’s not quite the ideal lighting for shooting photos. Here, the Moto G5 Plus produces a brighter photo than the others, but the Mi A1 and Moto G5S Plus produce more true to source photos. In brightening the photo, the Moto 5 Plus softens details by a bit. But again, you’ll see this difference in side by side comparisons only. Also, notice the blown out effect on the light, which increases from the Mi A1 to the Moto G5S Plus.

Left to right: Xiaomi Mi A1, Moto G5 Plus, Moto G5S Plus

Sample 5:

With its dual-pixel camera, the Moto G5 Plus should do well in low light. And it does, as shown below. In low light, the Moto G5 Plus produced the brightest shot and best white balance amongst the competitors here. While the Mi A1 produced an underwhelming and darker image, while the Moto G5S Plus completely lost white balance here.

Top to bottom: Xiaomi Mi A1, Moto G5 Plus, Moto G5S Plus

Sample 6:

This shot is clicked under incandescent lighting, so a yellowish tone should be expected. And looking at the images, you will see that the Mi A1 is the best camera in this case. The phone produces good details for a budget camera and deals with the lighting accurately. The Moto G5 Plus does a decent job with details, but it reduces the impact of the incandescent light. On the other hand, the Moto G5S Plus once again loses white balance completely, while also removing the incandescent effect.

Left to right: Xiaomi Mi A1, Moto G5 Plus, Moto G5S Plus

Sample 7:

This photo is again clicked under incandescent lighting, and the Mi A1 comes out on top once again. However, this photo shows you the difference in sharpness. The Xiaomi Mi A1 produces the sharpest image here, while the Moto G5 Plus comes in second. The Moto G5S Plus once again comes in last.

Left to right: Xiaomi Mi A1, Moto G5 Plus, Moto G5S Plus

Xiaomi Mi A1 Samples

Xiaomi Mi A1 Samples

Moto G5 Plus Samples

Moto G5 Plus

Moto G5S Plus samples

Moto G5S Plus

Speed:

Shooting with phone cameras isn’t just about image quality though. How fast a camera can shoot and process photos is a very important element. And the Mi A1 is by far the fastest of the three here. Both Motorola phones take a long time to focus and process photos, whereas the Mi A1 is significantly quicker and hence more dependable.

Best budget camera:

The speed and the fact that it can do bokeh/zoom photos better than the other two phones makes the Mi A1 the best budget camera today. While the Moto G5 Plus can go toe to toe with this phone for regular occurrences, the Mi A1 is faster and more dependable.

Moto G5S Plus Key Specs, Price and Launch Date

Price:
Release Date: 02 Aug 2017
Variant: 32GB , 64GB
Market Status: Launched

Key Specs

  • Screen Size Screen Size
    5.5" (1080 x 1920)
  • Camera Camera
    13 + 13 MP | 8 MP
  • Memory Memory
    64 GB/4 GB
  • Battery Battery
    3000 mAh
logo
Prasid Banerjee

Trying to explain technology to my parents. Failing miserably.

Digit caters to the largest community of tech buyers, users and enthusiasts in India. The all new Digit in continues the legacy of Thinkdigit.com as one of the largest portals in India committed to technology users and buyers. Digit is also one of the most trusted names when it comes to technology reviews and buying advice and is home to the Digit Test Lab, India's most proficient center for testing and reviewing technology products.

We are about leadership-the 9.9 kind! Building a leading media company out of India.And,grooming new leaders for this promising industry.

DMCA.com Protection Status