GTA Recap: Liberty City was rotten before Claude got there

With GTA VI just a couple of days away, Rockstar is taking us back to Vice City on November 19. However, for Recap #3, we’re heading to the other big GTA city: Liberty City. So far we’ve gone from Vice City Stories and Vice City to San Andreas. Now we’re covering two games set in the same place: Liberty City Stories and GTA III. It’s a good time to revisit these two because Liberty City shows a different side of the series from the sunny Vice City we’re about to return to. For the ones who haven't played these two games, Liberty City Stories takes place three years before GTA III.
We’ll take them one at a time and see what Liberty City was like before and after Claude showed up.
Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories
We play as Toni Cipriani, who returns to Liberty City after spending four years away. He’d been living under the radar after killing a made man for Salvatore Leone. Once back, he again starts to work for the Leone family, where he first takes jobs from Vincenzo Cilli. But Vincenzo, being a crook, treats him like his slave boy, causing conflicts between them which ultimately led to their partnership ending when he tries to have Toni killed. However, Toni, being the protagonist, fights back and starts working directly for Salvatore.
Afterwards, Toni helps the Leones fight the Sindacco and Forelli families, and also takes jobs from businessman Donald Love. Love wants to make money from a redevelopment project, so he asks Toni to help him get rid of his former mentor, Avery Carrington, and destroy Fort Staunton.
But there's more to the story than all the gang fights: Massimo Torini, a member of the Sicilian Mafia, has been pushing the gangs into conflict to weaken the Leones. He frames Salvatore, who ends up in jail. In the final stretch, Torini kidnaps Mayor Miles O’Donovan to stop him from clearing Salvatore’s name. Toni and Salvatore go after him, rescue the mayor, and kill Torini.
Why I love GTA: Liberty City Stories
For me, Liberty City Stories is a top-three GTA game. Not because of the gameplay; other games do that better, but because of how hard it commits to its story about power and corruption. Almost everyone in Liberty City is awful: Salvatore, Donald Love, Toni’s mother, the cops, pretty much the whole lot. Donald Love might be the worst of them. The city feels like the real main character, with everyone fighting over it.
Toni becomes a made man and earns Salvatore’s respect, but it doesn’t really get him anywhere. He stays a pawn, with no real growth, and in GTA III he’s still living with his mother. Toshiko is the one person who gets him thinking about life beyond crime, but she’s gone before anything can change. That bleakness is the point. Liberty City Stories is dark, nasty, and fully committed to showing a city trapped in a loop of power and violence. That’s why I love it.
Grand Theft Auto III
The game starts with Claude and Catalina robbing a bank. During their escape, Catalina betrays Claude, shoots and leaves him behind to get caught. He’s arrested, but a Colombian Cartel attack on the police convoy gives him a chance to escape with 8-Ball. Claude then makes it his main goal to find Catalina and get even.
He starts out doing jobs for the Leone family, helping them fight the Triads. But Salvatore eventually decides Claude has become a problem and plans to get rid of him. However, Maria, Salvatore’s wife, warns him about the same and helps him get out of Portland. She introduces Claude to Asuka Kasen, a Yakuza leader, leading to Claude working for her and getting pulled into a fight with the Cartel.
Later, Claude takes jobs from Donald Love (yes, the same guy from the Liberty City Stories). While working on one of Love's assigned jobs, Claude comes face to face with Catalina again. He finds that she’s now leading the Cartel. However, Catalina, being the villain, shoots her new partner (deja vu), Miguel, and escapes.
Catalina, to get back at Claude again, kills Asuka and kidnaps Maria. She then asks a ransom from Claude if he wants to see Maria again. Claude agrees and pays her, but she betrays him again. Fueled by his anger, Claude follows her to Cochrane Dam and brings down her helicopter. He rescues Maria and finally gets his revenge.
My take on GTA III
GTA III is a landmark game, but going back to it now can be rough. Liberty City still has a great atmosphere, and the missions often let you figure things out your own way. But the controls feel dated, and some missions are punishing when there are no checkpoints and gangs keep coming after you. If you started with GTA IV or GTA V, it can feel pretty bare next to them. I’d still say it’s worth playing to see where the 3D GTA games took off. Just don’t expect it to feel as smooth as Vice City or San Andreas.
Vikhyat Rishi is the Chief Copy Editor at Digit, where he covers home appliances. His work spans reviews, buying guides, comparisons, features, and explainers across the category. Before joining Digit, he worked with Beebom, Smartprix, and iGeeks, covering smartphones, computers, software, gaming, and consumer technology. His work combines editorial experience with a focus on practical insights and real-world product usage.
View full profile

