Why Jensen Huang shouldn't return as CEO of NVIDIA, and why he should

Highlights

Jensen Huang’s greatest legacy could be proving NVIDIA survives without him

NVIDIA’s succession crisis exposes the risks of indispensable leadership

Despite compelling arguments for his return, NVIDIA must move forward

Just think about this for a second, can one man be bigger than the sum of all parts that encompass his creation? I won’t deny there’s a part of me that won’t just like but wants Jensen Huang back as CEO of NVIDIA. But I also want to look ahead beyond the hero-worshipped cult figure of Jensen Huang and hope NVIDIA’s board of directors stick to their guns. 

And increasingly, it’s becoming difficult to pick the right course of action, because Jensen Huang’s stepping down as CEO of NVIDIA may seem simple on the surface but it’s highly complicated if you try to wrap your head around it all.

Before I get into it, I must say that of all the things I’d imagined coming even remotely close to disrupting NVIDIA’s dominance in the AI age – AMD, rise of custom silicon, the Chinese semiconductor industry, the AI bubble popping hard – Jensen Huang himself wasn’t on my bingo card. And yet, here we are. It’s peak Jensanity and NVIDIA’s caught in the middle of it all.

Why Jensen shouldn’t return to NVIDIA

NVIDIA is on a generational roll right now, one of the most valuable companies in the world at the centre of the AI boom, and it’s largely down to Huang’s stewardship. In 2024, Huang famously spoke about having 60 direct reportees at NVIDIA, which is unheard of for any conventional big enterprise – tech or no. What was celebrated then as an unconventional masterstroke of management now, in hindsight, seems like an epic disaster from a succession planning perspective. 

Because, how do you begin to replace someone who’s designed the entire organisational structure around himself? This is one of the biggest self-goals of Jensen Huang as the CEO of NVIDIA, I have to admit – whether you love him or not.

At 63, after 33 years at the helm of NVIDIA, Huang isn't getty any younger – he would eventually have had to confront the uncomfortable question of succession sooner or later. While the circumstances of his resignation are extraordinary, when he’s already out of the company, why endure the pain of letting him go twice? It doesn’t make sense, if you think about it logically.

Yes, Jensen Huang is the reason behind a lot of personal rapport with Taiwan-based silicon manufacturing giants, his stories of doing business over simple handshakes (with little to no legal contracts) are legendary. But NVIDIA isn’t the little graphics card company of the 1990s anymore. Its business interests influence matters of national security, international energy policy and the economic ambitions of nation states. How long can all of that hinge on one human being? High time NVIDIA institutionalises some of the business relationships that have historically based on Huang’s personal equation with industry counterparts.

Then there’s the uncomfortable questions about nepotism, of having his children employed at NVIDIA. It doesn’t matter whether they’ve the merit for their job, questions around preferential treatment should need greater scrutiny – NVIDIA isn’t a family heirloom after all.

And what better time to address all these questions and enact sweeping changes than just after a record-breaking quarter of $115.8 billion in revenue? If NVIDIA can’t survive without Jensen Huang now, when the tech and finances are at their peak, wouldn’t a transition at the helm be worse during a downward turn in the future?

Why Jensen should return as CEO of NVIDIA

After making the case against Jensanity, there’s something deeply unsettling about the manner in which one of the greatest CEO runs in corporate history has come to a shockingly abrupt end. And you can’t just sweep it under the carpet or look away.

I’m not a national security expert, but given all the reporting I’ve read on this accusation against Jensen Huang – that he had an affair with an alleged Chinese spy – I think a distinction should be made between being the target of a foreign intelligence operation and willingly participating in one. Until the facts on this matter come out, surely Jensen Huang deserves the benefit of the doubt?

Then, of course, there’s the small matter of actually running NVIDIA. Establishing a technological roadmap of several years into the future, managing all the relationships with foundries, memory manufacturers, software and tech giants, and hundreds of large customers around the world. From the outside looking in, Jensen made it all seem deceptively easy.

That’s the reason why NVIDIA’s stock plunged nearly 10% in immediately after news of his departure broke. That’s why employees, industry veterans, investors, Elon Musk and even Donald Trump have rallied behind the idea of Jensen Huang returning to NVIDIA. 

Silicon Valley has already seen one such extraordinary comeback in Sam Altman’s return to OpenAI in 2023. It must be said that a reinstated Jensen Huang could operate under greater institutional oversight from NVIDIA’s new board chairman, Harvey Jones.

“I own my mistakes completely,” Huang said in his statement on November 17, his first words since his bombshell resignation. Surely there’s room for redemption?

All things considered…

As much as I’d love to see the familiar black leather jacket back on stage at GTC, I think NVIDIA, and the rest of the semiconductor ecosystem it rallies, needs to learn to live without Jensen Huang.

But there’s no doubt Jensen Huang still has a lot to offer to the world of tech. If the board investigation against him goes in his favour, then Jensen should comeback as a technology ambassador for NVIDIA, evangelising its computing marvels without having to run the company day-to-day.

Ultimately, as the man who made himself indispensable to NVIDIA, perhaps Jensen Huang’s greatest contribution to the company he built and grew from nothing would be to prove that he isn't.

Jayesh Shinde

Jayesh Shinde Executive Editor at Digit. Technology journalist since Jan 2008, with stints at Indiatimes.com and PCWorld.in. Enthusiastic dad, reluctant traveler, weekend gamer, LOTR nerd, pseudo bon vivant.

View full profile