Western Digital Scorpio Blue 750 GB - Notebook storage gets a shot in the arm Review

| Published Date
02 - Mar - 2011
| Last Updated
02 - Mar - 2011
 
8215
Western Digital Scorpio Blue 750 GB - Notebook storage gets a shot in the arm

    Western Digital Scorpio Blue 750 GB - Notebook storage gets a shot in the arm Price in India

  • 8215/-

Western Digital Scorpio Blue 750 GB - Notebook storage gets a shot in the arm Rating 0100100

Our Verdict

750 GB is a lot of storage space. And the WD7500BVPT is a good performer. If you ignore the high MSRP (Rs. 8,215) and look to the street, you can find this drive for as little as Rs. 6,400 - a price point at which we cannot complain. 500 GB is at the sweet spot for capacity versus price however, and these drives are disproportionately cheaper. It will take a while for 750 GB to become the norm. If you can wait, prices might fall further within six months. However, if you need the space, and can afford to shell out, you'll definitely not be disappointed.

PROS

  • Good performance, at par with slower desktop drives
  • Just two platters and runs cooler as a result
  • Large storage capacity
  • Current street prices indicate reasonably good value

CONS

  • Performance still not at par with 7,200 rpm drives
  • WD provides a 3 year warranty for this drive, unlike 5 years for the Black Edition drives

Western Digital Scorpio Blue 750 GB - Notebook storage gets a shot in the arm: Detailed Review

With the entry of massive 3-terabyte drives in the desktop space, it's all too easy to forget advancements made in the notebook hard drive arena. And these are technologically harder to achieve. Notebook drives have a much smaller form factor than their desktop counterparts, despite the seemingly meagre one-inch difference in quoted size, notebook drives are positively diminutive when compared to desktop drives. They also have to produce less heat and less noise. Unfortunately, they don't get any concessions in terms of speed, for we run the same operating systems on them. We also received a shiny new Western Digital Black Edition WDC WD75000BPKT, which was announced at the CES 2011, that we will test shortly, and compare it to the Scorpio Blue 750 GB. The Blue Edition notebook drives are Western Digital's answer to those looking for a value-oriented notebook solution, since there are no Green Edition options in the 2.5-inch form factor.

WD Scorpio Blue 750GB

Look and Feel

It's a hard drive, so there isn't much to say about it, but the Western Digital Scorpio Blue 750 GB is neatly designed. Weighing in at 150 grams, the PCB has been tightly pressed against the drive body, obviously to prevent any component from touching any external surface. Additionally, the components on the PCB can dissipate some heat by being in touch with the metal casing enclosing the platters. The drive itself is slim, in fact slimmer than some of the 250 GB notebook drives we've seen a couple of years back. Western Digital's "Blue" moniker is easy to spot - all their drives are colour coded, Black Editions have black graphics, and so on. Owing to its compactness, the drive also feels pretty solid. The build lines are pretty tight.

Features

[RELATED_ARTICLE]The model number for this Western Digital Scorpio Blue 750 GB is WDC WD7500BVPT. Weighing a mere 150 grams, it is based on a two-platter design. This means Western Digital managed to cram a massive 375 GB on each platter of the Scorpio Blue 750 GB - quite an achievement, considering that a year ago, this was the maximum amount of data that could be packed on to a 3.5-inch platter! The Scorpio Blue 750 GB has a SATA 2.0 interface, and a buffer of 8 megabytes. Western Digital claims a read/write power consumption of 1.6 watts, and an idle power consumption of 0.65 watts. The WD7500BVPT comes with a standard 3 year warranty. Note that Black Edition drives sport a 5 year warranty.

 

Click next to read about its performance and our final take

 

Performance

During operation, the drive is pretty silent, definitely more so than desktop drives, but then it needs to be, because notebooks sit a lot closer to your ears than desktop cabinets. Given that the rotational speed is 5,400 rpm, we weren't expecting very hot performance. Given our expectations, we were pleasantly surprised. In fact, it is at times faster than a Western Digital 2 TB Green Edition (WD 20EADS). We've decided to do a very interesting comparison by introducing other desktop drives and even an SSD. We're refraining from showing figures of the Western Digital WD75000BPK in this test, since WD themselves haven't even given us its pricing yet. However, expect to see that reviewed soon.

WD 7500BVPT Scorpio Blue 750 GB performance graph

The WD7500BPVT Scorpio Blue 750 GB is nearly at par with, and often supersedes the WD 2 TB Green Edition desktop drive - high praise indeed. It has very strong sequential read/write performance, and is definitely one of the faster notebook drives we've seen

Obviously, the puny WD7500BVPT is no match for faster desktop drives, or SSDs, but then, it is not expected to be. However, when compared to a Western Digital Green Edition 2 TB, the Scorpio Blue 750 GB is no slouch. In fact, it manages to shame its larger counterpart is a few real world tests, enough for us to conclude that the drive is at least, nearly as good. It has a very respectable sequential file write speed of 104.38 megabytes per second, and is barely 43 per cent slower than a Western Digital 2 TB Black Edition, which is one of the fastest 7,200 rpm drives of all time. The assorted write test, where we write a lot of small files of variable sizes, is the most demanding of our gamut of real world tests, and this is the only place where the little newcomer lags behind, by a margin of around 22 per cent. Comparing it to ADATA's S599 we see the WD7500BVPT getting left behind as SiSoft Sandra 2010 rates the S599 as three and a half times speedier at reads, and three times faster at writes. However, comparisons with an SSD might not be fair, given the price of solid-state storage at the moment.

WD 7500BVPT Scorpio Blue 750 GB price comparison

Obviously, less is better here. SSDs like the A-Data S599 are pretty weak when it comes to the price paid for the storage you get, at 100 Rupees per GB, this is not for the data glut. The WD7500BVPT might seem relatively expensive, compared to desktop drives. In fact, it is expensive compared to 250 GB and 500 GB notebook drives as well, but by a much smaller margin. Note that we have used street prices

 

Our take

[RELATED_ARTICLE]Western Digital quotes an MSRP (recommended MRP) of Rs. 8,215, and that is a bit expensive. However, we were able to find the WD7500BVPT Scorpio Blue 750 GB for as low as Rs. 6,400 in shops. This is a very good price point for a drive of this class. Inevitably, people will compare this price to desktop drives and find it wanting, however, such comparisons are unfair. Considering you get a massive (for a notebook drive) 750 GB and performance at par with a WD 20EADS Green Edition 2 TB - the WD7500BVPT is a great deal at its street price. If you need a massive amount of storage space on your notebook, this is definitely worth considering.

Specifications: Capacity: 750 GB; No. of platters: 2; Buffer: 8 MB; spindle speed: 5,400 rpm; weight: 150 grams

Rating:
Features: 7
Performance: 6.5
Build: 7
Value: 7.5
Overall: 7.5

 

BrandWD
Model NameScorpio Blue
Model NumberWDC WD7500BPVT
Price (Rs)8,215 (MSRP)
Features 
HDD capacity (GB)750GB
InterfaceSATA
Number of Platters 
Rotational Speed (RPM)5400
Buffer Size (MB)8
Performance 
Synthetic Tests 
SiSoft Sandra 2010 (Engineer) 
Drive Index, Read (MBps)73.15
Access Time, read (milliseconds)17.46
Drive Index, Write (MBps)65.83
Access time, write (milliseconds) *13.88
Real World Tests 
Write Single File (MBps)104.38
Write Test Assorted Files (MBps)62.61
Read Test Single File (MBps)106.52
Read Test Assorted Files (MBps)86.6
PhotoShop CS2 (1 GB File, in seconds) *54.83
* less is better 

 

Company Name: Western Digital
Contact: Srinivas Sampangi
Email: Srinivas.Sampangi@wdc.com
Cell: 9880293193
Website: www.wdc.com
Price: Rs. 8,215 (MSRP)

Latest Forum discussions on Western Digital Scorpio Blue 750 GB - Notebook storage gets a shot in the arm

  • Western digital scorpio black (wd7500bpkt) 750gb notebook drive

    This is the second 750GB Notebook drive review I am going put up, this one is from Western...

    1. The sorcerer15/03/2011
      Western Digital India finally announces it: [QUOTE]WD Scorpio Black 750 GB hard drives (model number WD7500BPKT) are available now at your nearest retailer. MSRP for the WD Scorpio Black 750 GB hard drive is Rs. 5275 plus taxes. WD Scorpio Black 750 GB hard drives are covered by a five-year limited warranty. [/QUOTE]
    2. Ps23079314/07/2011
      The review is very good and enlightening..... I got a macbook pro 13" early 2011 edition with that slow 500gb hdd. Can I replace that with this one? I know its very late but could you help me? Please can you tell me that whether it would work properly with it without any compatibility issues or something....? Thanks for help.
    3. The sorcerer14/07/2011
      Not sure of macbook pro 13 inch- sorry. But I can find out and let you know by monday.
    Show More
  • Western 750 gb external hdd

    Friends, I need to buy a 750 GB external HDD for storing movies/documentaries/eBooks etc. The 400 GB one that I have is already full :mad: , So I was thinking of going for [URL="http://www.amazon.co.uk/Western-Digital-Essential-USB2-0-External/dp/B000SKJDWS/ref=pd_bbs_1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1196471752&sr=8-1"]this [/URL]. Need your feedback...

    1. Metalheadgautham01/12/2007
      Hope this helps:(taken from digit july, so prices may be outdated and hence lower.) Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD5000AAKS is good 500GB internal 1.57 Paise per MB Rs.7500/- Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD3200AAKS is good 320GB internal 1.47 Paise per MB RS.4500/- (from digit july :oops:) these are better than most 750 GB HDDs out there get...
    2. Royal01/12/2007
      [quote=MetalheadGautham]these are better than most 750 GB HDDs out there[/quote] Can I know the reason ? :confused: Not challenging you but just asking . [quote=MetalheadGautham]get a casing for Rs. 600/- and chuck them in. You get longer guarentee for the HDDs, more value for money, and no chance of refurbished HDDs found in some external...
    3. Choto cheeta02/12/2007
      @royal Are you buying from UK ?? if yes then consider this, [url]http://store.apple.com/1-800-MY-APPLE/WebObjects/AppleStore.woa/wa/RSLID?mco=47E21721&fnode=home&nplm=TQ587ZM/A[/url] as with apple you get an Internation warrenty so no matter where you go you can obtain warrenty :) price is also pretty low when you are out side india and paying...
    Show More
  • Western digital caviar blue wd5000aakx sata 6g/s storage

    SATA 6G/s drives are coming in hot and fresh as WD India sends me a WD5000AAKX drive for evaluation [url=http://s1112.photobucket.com/albums/k500/HardwareBBQ/AAKX/?action=view&current=IMG_0564.jpg][img]http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k500/HardwareBBQ/AAKX/IMG_0564.jpg[/img][/url] [u][b]Pics, Specs and First...

    1. Saswat2320/05/2011
      But where on the disc is it written that its SATA3 i.e SATA6Gbps
    2. Sam05/06/2011
      the model no i.e. [B]AAKX[/B] tells whether it is Sata3 or Sata2. Green or Blue.
    3. Saswat2305/06/2011
      Then check for 2nd the pic above. What exactly is written under the sl no. What does that 3Gbps mean. I have the very same HDD. So, if i connect the HDD to SATA3 port of my mobo then will i get SATA 6Gbps performance...
    Show More
  • Query: western digital caviar green 500 gb?

    I am interested in buying western digital caviar grenn 500 Gb hdd. i would like to know [B]the Rpm [/B]of the same.(ie 7200 RPM Or 5400 RPM)(I couldn't find the info in the wd website) Plz reply. Also watz the diff between caviar green and cAaviar balck. I am gamer which one should i buy?(ie green or black)

    1. Desiibond25/08/2009
      If you can pay 6.5k for 1Tb HDD, WD Caviar Black is the way to go coz: # Dual processor - Twice the processing power to maximize performance. # 32 MB cache - Bigger, faster cache means faster performance. Rock Solid Mechanical Architecture # StableTrac - The motor shaft is secured at both ends to reduce system-induced vibration and stabilize...
    2. Zbuu25/08/2009
      i dont need 1tb. for nw 500 gb willl do. do knw the price of wd 500 gb avaiar balck.?
    3. Desiibond25/08/2009
      Black edition starts at 750Gb but in India I think only 1Tb is available.
    Show More
  • Western digital to acquire hitachi global storage technologies

    [IMG]http://i.imgur.com/SPHNn.jpg[/IMG][IMG]http://i.imgur.com/x4n9m.png[/IMG][IMG]http://i.imgur.com/evvP3.jpg[/IMG][IMG]http://i.imgur.com/yotPk.jpg[/IMG] [QUOTE]"The acquisition of Hitachi GST is a unique opportunity for WD to create further value for our customers, stockholders, employees, suppliers and the communities in which we operate,"...

    1. Tech.masti08/03/2011
      good news, thanx.... :)