Motorola Moto E (2nd Gen) 3G Review

| Published Date
16 - Mar - 2015
| Last Updated
04 - Dec - 2016
 
5999

Where to buy

66
The new Moto E is not a bad device, but it pales in comparison to its competitors. The market has changed now and Motorola needs to realise that.

Motorola Moto E (2nd Gen) 3G Rating 66100100

Our Verdict

The Moto E (2nd Gen) is definitely not a bad smartphone, but it makes no sense in the current market. The newer hardware on the Redmi 2 and Lenovo A6000 are both more powerful and already have 4G compatibility. The Moto E just doesn't provide the value that they do.

PROS

  • Lollipop out of the box
  • Good build quality

CONS

  • Poor front and rear cameras
  • Not the performer that competitors are
  • 3G only

Motorola Moto E (2nd Gen) 3G: Detailed Review

When Motorola announced the original Moto E, it was a treat for all of us, and that includes reviewers all over the world. The company showcased why it is one of the pioneers of mobile technology and turned the mobile market head over heels. Motorola showed that you don’t need to shell out month’s salary to get a good device and gave us what was truly a phone for the people.

Fast forward one year ahead, the new Moto E is now here. And it reminds me of that famous comic book adage, “With great power comes great responsibility.” I’ve read a bunch of reviews from my counterparts overseas, who have all appreciated this device. But for us, the Moto E is a much more important smartphone than it is for them. Why? Most of the smartphone buyers in India, buy in the budget segment.

The Moto E (2nd Gen) is a good device, no doubt, but the contest in the budget segment in India is very different from other countries. In a head to head battle against its competitors, like the Xiaomi Redmi 2 and Lenovo A6000, the new Moto E takes a beating. Here’s how.

Build and Design

On the design front, the new Moto E is essentially an extension of the older one. But there’s a few subtle changes that make this one so much better. The rubberised grip around the side, which hides the SIM and micro-SD slots is very important. It adds grip and will absorb shocks as well. In addition, it gives the phone a unique look, unlike any other.

Motorola’s design philosophy was always more ergonomic than others, but I’ll go as far as to call the new Moto E a beautiful budget device. Why? Because it’s different. That rubber grip, which is available in various colours, makes it stand out against all the bar designs that we get to see these days. Add the curved back and small size and you’ve got a device that’s both easy to use and good looking for its price.

The company adds a solid build on top of this, to leave almost nothing to complain about in the build and design segment. That is, until you see the Xiaomi Redmi 2. There’s a reason why the Chinese firm launched its competitor a few days after Motorola. The Redmi 2, though carrying the boring old bar design, is a better looking phone, which is just as ergonomic. I’m almost finished with that review as well, so watch out for more.

Display

A 4.5 inch display is just about acceptable these days, but a 540x960p resolution isn’t. At the same price, you have the Redmi 2 and Lenovo A6000, which both offer 720p resolutions. The Moto E’s display has a better touch experience than the A6000, but it isn’t in the same league as the Xiaomi Redmi 2 display in terms of colors reproduction and sharpness. Yes, we now demand and expect a lot more from a Rs. 7,000 device, a lot has changed since the last Moto E launch. The Moto E’s display does redeem itself, delivering better viewing angles and a lesser reflective display than the Xiaomi Redmi 2. But, overall we’d place the Redmi 2 display above the Moto E, the Redmi scores higher in crucial aspects of the display, especially for a 7K smartphone segment.

OS and User Interface

The Moto E runs on Android Lollipop out of the box and is the only one in this range to do so at the moment. The UI is smooth, with little to no lags and Motorola has brought some useful features to the device. The Moto Display, which shows your notifications without turning the screen on is one of these features, while the Quick Capture feature is also pretty useful for taking quick shots through the camera.

Performance

Me and a bunch of my colleagues from other publications pestered Motorola a lot about choosing the Snapdragon 200 over the newer 410 SoC. Considering that the company went with the 64-bit Lollipop OS for the Moto E, the Snapdragon 410 seems like the logical choice. Nevertheless, Motorola was adamant that the performance wouldn’t suffer because of this.

Well, that’s not true. Using it side by side with the Redmi 2 and Lenovo A6000, the Moto E is inferior. Yes, the Moto E offers a more uniform performance than the A6000, but pales in comparison to the Mi device. On regular usage, app launch times and the overall UI experience on the Moto E are pretty satisfactory, but start a game like Marvel: Contest of Champions and the lags creep in. Not only does the game load faster on the Redmi 2, the Moto E makes the Mi device seem like a mid-ranged smartphone.

 

The benchmarks don’t tell the entire story here. The Redmi 2 and Lenovo A6000 are both much more powerful than Moto E.

Camera

Motorola’s compromise on the camera quality used to make sense till last year, because the company got things right in every other department. This time around though, the 5MP rear camera on the Moto E seems worse because of all the other shortcomings. You may be able to take some passable shots with this camera under optimal light conditions, but anything less and you’re looking at really bad images. It is essentially the same camera as the old Moto E, but with auto focus.

While we’re talking about the camera, Motorola ‘heard’ its users this time around and added a VGA camera to the front. Yes, you read that right, a VGA camera, all 0.3 mega pixels of it. For some reason the company thought that was the way to go. Frankly, I would trade the front camera for a faster processor in a heartbeat.

Battery

The one thing that all of us here at the Digit test labs were looking forward to was the larger 2390 mAh battery. Better battery life could make up for a lot of the device’s faults. Sadly though, the Moto E doesn't show any major improvements here. The results on our battery tests were just about satisfactory. With some frugality, I could get the device to last me through the day, just like I could with the older Moto E.

 

The battery life is at par with the Redmi 2 and Lenovo A6000.

Bottomline

As that adage goes, “With great power comes great responsibility.” In my humble opinion, Motorola had the opportunity to deliver the knockout punch to its competition, but failed. The 3G version of the Moto E (2nd Gen) is not one that you should buy. At least not as long as you can buy the Xiaomi Redmi 2 or the Lenovo A6000.

Going with a Snapdragon 410 SoC would have still made this device an incremental update, but combined with Motorola’s brand value and increased customer service efforts, it would have made sense. As things stand though, the 3G version of the Moto E isn’t as value for money as it used to be. It’s not the best device you can buy in the under-7k segment, ahead only of Microsoft’s Lumia 532 and 435. What's even more unfortunate is that the needless 3G/4G skews for the Moto E will drive up the price of the Snapdragon 410-powered 4G variant. That may make it a lesser value device as compared to the Redmi 2, which is already 4G capable.

Buy Moto E (2nd Gen) on Flipkart at Rs. 6,999

Latest Forum discussions on Motorola Moto E 2nd Gen 3G

  • Moto e 2nd gen announced

    [QUOTE]It turns out that the rumors were spot on, Motorola's new handset is indeed a 4G LTE version of its popular Moto E smartphone, but that isn't the only improvement made to Motorola's low cost offering. As well as faster data speeds in a budget package, the second generation Moto E moves up from a dual-core to 1.2GHz quad-core Qualcomm...

    1. Saiyangoku25/02/2015
      They've lost the VFM factor due to pricing IMHO. :|
    2. Kkn1326/02/2015
      so the Moto E 2 is actually a Moto G 1 LTE except for display and a few more things might as well get Moto G2 for the 2k more
    3. $hadow26/02/2015
      Moto g 3rd gen will be a lot interesting from my point of view. I am going in for a SD600 series processor since moto e now has SD 410
    Show More
  • Moto e 2nd gen 3g : buy or not

    I want to buy this budget phone in single sim variant. It meet my requirements and currently selling on FlipKart for ₹7000 . I just want to make a final confirmation from your side that whether I should go for it or my findings were wrong? Also suggest me for genuine flip cover for the device ... Thanks for your valuable time :)

    1. Saiyangoku30/06/2015
      Fill the questionnaire
    2. Reddick30/06/2015
      Questionnaire : 1. Budget - From 6K to 10K 2. Display type and size - The best around 4.5" 3. Dual sim - No 4. Preferred choice of brand - Moto E 2nd Gen 3G 5. What camera option you want (flash, front facing camera) - Better to have all features :p 6. Preferred operating system? (Android, iOS, Windows Phone, etc) - Android 7. Preferred...
    3. Saiyangoku30/06/2015
      If you are getting Moto E2 3g for 5.5k, go for it. Else get Yuphoria for 7k, Moto E2 4g for 6-6.5k.
    Show More
  • [help]moto e 2nd gen stuck in booting loop

    Hello Folks, Returning to TDF after a long time :razz:. Need some urgent advice, My Moto E 2nd Gen is stuck in a booting loop at the Motorola Logo, I tried the hard boot and Factory reset but it goes into the loop again. The phone is 4 months old and is still in Warranty, Any suggestions on how to fix it myself if at all possible ? Any...

    1. $hadow10/07/2015
      rooted via toolkit or adb?
    2. Minion11/07/2015
      follow this guide no need to go to service center [url=http://www.gammerson.com/2015/04/how-to-restoreflash-stock-fimware-in.html]How to Restore/Flash Stock Firmware In Moto E 2nd gen 2015 | Gammerson[/url]
  • Moto g 2nd gen unable to hear voice

    I got my moto g 2nd gen on 19th. I am experiencing strange issues , Sometimes When someone calls me i am unable to hear anything for callers side , switching from earpiece to speakers also gives no sound. It happens quite often , but randomly , and once it happens , even if I make a call i am unable to hear anything. Restarting the phone...

    1. Sam25/10/2014
      my friend's Moto G had similar problem with cracking noise whenever he calls someone. have it replaced.
    2. Vineetpratik25/10/2014
      ok then i shall be applying for a replacement , I haven't done it before so it would be really helpful if someone could guide me a bit about getting it returned hand to hand , instead of first sending it to WSRetail and then waiting for them to send it back to me. Thanks
    3. Theserpent25/10/2014
      [QUOTE=vineetpratik;2172429]ok then i shall be applying for a replacement , I haven't done it before so it would be really helpful if someone could guide me a bit about getting it returned hand to hand , instead of first sending it to WSRetail and then waiting for them to send it back to me. Thanks[/QUOTE] They will call you after you request for...
    Show More
  • The moto x 1st and 2nd gen discussion

    Say {Hello to Moto} again, which this premium device that is the basis of Nexus 6. From Active Display which may seem like a gimmick but is actually very useful and saves battery life in the long run, to Touchless control which very aptly shown in the ads provides you a way to give commands to your phone without ever touching, its one phone that...

    1. Vyom17/10/2014
      List of Moto X Owners: (XT 1052) [MENTION=77264]Vyom[/MENTION] [MENTION=266361]kunalgujarathi[/MENTION] [MENTION=288626]polupoka[/MENTION] [MENTION=155555]Superayush[/MENTION] [MENTION=32982]Baker[/MENTION] List of Moto X2 Owners: (XT 1092) [MENTION=23425]gopi_vbboy[/MENTION] ...
    2. Vyom17/10/2014
      ~ [I]Reserved for Realm of rooted world[/I] ~
    3. Amjath17/10/2014
      ^Wow thread, I was thinking why no Moto X thread whne Moto G thread exsist thanks for the thread [MENTION=77264]Vyom[/MENTION] It is good to point that 4G LTE doesnt work on Moto X 2013 India. Just in case any one interested
    Show More

Customer Reviews

  • 4.4
    Based on 1477 rating