Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED
Menu

digit

 

Results 1 to 13 of 13

Thread: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

  1. #1
    Right off the assembly line
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Posts
    1

    Default Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED - what is the difference in picture quality?

  2. #2
    Human Spambot randomuser111's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    2,419

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    Full Array LED without Local Dimming is worse than Edge LED

    Full Array LED with Local Dimming is far superior to Edge LED.

  3. #3
    Human Spambot
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Soul Society
    Posts
    8,108

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    Full array LED costs above 1.5 lacs
    HTC One V | Gionee P2 | Nikon D3100 | Apple Ipod Touch 4G | SM ES18 | Casio Edifice EX106 | WD My Passport 1 TB | Seagate Backup Plus Slim 500GB
    ~~~~~~~~~~~
    God helps those who help others

  4. #4
    Wise Old Owl
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Bangalore
    Posts
    1,650

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    ^^full led are being used in samsung EH series tvs which are budget leds tvs.

    Quote Originally Posted by randomuser111 View Post
    Full Array LED without Local Dimming is worse than Edge LED
    Full array led are much better than edge led tvs.You will not face problem like banding,clouding,flashing etc screen will be uniform.disadvantage is these are not slim like edge led.

    @vikas33
    Read this
    http://hometheater.about.com/od/televisions/qt/ledlcdtvfacts.htm
    http://reviews.cnet.com/2795-6482_7-399.html

  5. #5
    Human Spambot randomuser111's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    2,419

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    ^

    Nope. These cheap full array LEDs use lesser LEDs than EDGE LED models and as such have poor PQ. You can check the reviews on any website.

  6. #6
    TV Expert Sam22's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Location
    Delhi
    Posts
    234

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    The main difference between them and ones with backlights behind the screen is the thickness of the set. Picture wise there shouldn't be much if any difference. Edge lit sets are usually more expensive than equivalent normal backlight sets too.
    [B]Sony Xperia S, Dell Inspiron 15R, HCL ME 74.[/B]

  7. #7
    Alpha Geek reniarahim1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Pheonix, Arizona (AZ) / Cochin(KL) , IND
    Posts
    726

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    Quote Originally Posted by Minion View Post
    ^^full led are being used in samsung EH series tvs which are budget leds tvs.



    Full array led are much better than edge led tvs.You will not face problem like banding,clouding,flashing etc screen will be uniform.disadvantage is these are not slim like edge led.

    @vikas33
    Read this
    LED TV - The Truth About LED Televisions
    LED TVs compared: Local dimming, edge-lit, and full array - CNET Reviews
    No..What these low cost Samsung LED TVs use is Direct LED which is no where near to the Edge LEDs. See the below links ->

    Low-Cost Direct LED Backlights to Reduce Premium for LED-Backlit LCD TVs - DisplaySearch
    What is a direct-lit LED LCD TV?
    Dell Studio 1555 - Intel Core 2 Duo P8600 @ 2.40 GHz, 3 GB RAM, 500 GB HDD, ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4500 | PC - Intel Pentium G620 @ 2.60 GHz, Intel DH67CL, 4 GB RAM, 500 GB HDD | Nokia Lumia 720 | Moto-G 16GB

  8. #8
    Wise Old Owl
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Bangalore
    Posts
    1,650

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    Quote Originally Posted by randomuser111 View Post
    ^

    Nope. These cheap full array LEDs use lesser LEDs than EDGE LED models and as such have poor PQ. You can check the reviews on any website.
    I am saying they may not have great picture quality of higher end edge lit model due to absence of local dimming but screen uniformity is much better in back lit models.you will see black in black scenes not gray.
    See this
    LED Backlighting vs. Edgelighting | Home Theater

    Quote Originally Posted by reniarahim1 View Post
    No..What these low cost Samsung LED TVs use is Direct LED which is no where near to the Edge LEDs. See the below links ->

    Low-Cost Direct LED Backlights to Reduce Premium for LED-Backlit LCD TVs - DisplaySearch
    What is a direct-lit LED LCD TV?
    You can see advantages of direct lit tvs over edge lit tv when playing a dark scene in both tvs.In tv world what you pay for is what you get.

    One more thing i found is more contrast in led back lit model than old CCFL.

    Sony is selling three types of led tvs they are EX series are edge lit models,HX series are dynamic edge lit models (having local dimming features),HX 925 uses full led with local dimming.

    if you are saying direct lit led is a cheaper tech then why sony HX 925 is using it.
    Last edited by Minion; 28-09-2012 at 09:49 AM.

  9. #9
    LG Expert LGWRGreg's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Posts
    20

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    Quote Originally Posted by Minion View Post
    I am saying they may not have great picture quality of higher end edge lit model due to absence of local dimming but screen uniformity is much better in back lit models.you will see black in black scenes not gray.
    See this
    LED Backlighting vs. Edgelighting | Home Theater



    You can see advantages of direct lit tvs over edge lit tv when playing a dark scene in both tvs.In tv world what you pay for is what you get.

    One more thing i found is more contrast in led back lit model than old CCFL.

    Sony is selling three types of led tvs they are EX series are edge lit models,HX series are dynamic edge lit models (having local dimming features),HX 925 uses full led with local dimming.

    if you are saying direct lit led is a cheaper tech then why sony HX 925 is using it.
    LG WRman Greg here!

    There seems to be a bit of confusion with Direct-lit LED vs. Full-array LED. Both Direct-lit LED and Full-array LED have the LED backlights directly behind the panel as opposed to Edge-lit LED, which have the LED backlights on the edge of the panel while utilizing a light diffuser to (hopefully) evenly distribute the light throughout the screen. The main difference between Direct-lit LED vs Full-array LED is the number of LED lights used. Direct lit LED TVs have much fewer LED lights to use as a backlight. Due to this, the LED lights must be placed a bit further back than with edge-lit or Full-array LED TVs. This creates a bulkier size; however, the cost is significantly reduced while still retaining some of the benefits of having the backlight placed behind the panel.

    So if you were to assume that all LEDs used in TVs are the same (which they are not, but I'm just giving an example), in terms of screen uniformity, banding, etc., you can consider it this way: Edge-lit < Direct-lit < Full-array. However, as randomuser111 has said, not all LED lights are the same, so there will always be high-end Edge-lit TVs that perform better than Direct-lit TVs depending on the quality of the backlights. For example, the LM8600 uses an Edge-lit LED backlight, but the picture quality is still superb.

    I hope this clears up some confusion!

    LG WRman Greg, out!
    Last edited by LGWRGreg; 28-09-2012 at 10:37 AM.

  10. #10
    Apprentice Kirtu Jindal's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    Hyderabad
    Posts
    62

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    In edge lit LED TVs, the backlight for the LCD screen is provided by LEDS arranged along the edge of the panel. In the full array LED versions, the LEDs are arranged along the whole background of the screen. There is indeed a difference in performance of Edge Lit LED TVs vis-a-vis Full Array LED TVs - mostly in terms of contrast levels and brightness. In full array models, the LEDs in individual segments can be dimmed to create higher contrast. In the same way, since the whole screen background is lit, the brightness is also better. For these two reasons, full array LED TVs are considered to impart a better quality. However, since the number of LEDs needed are many times higher, it invariably leads to significant cost increase - hence this type of TV is more expensive. At present, there are no full array LED TV models in India (of any brand). However, LG is soon expected to introduce LG LM9600 (sometime around Diwali) - this will definitely be the first Full Array LED TV in India.

  11. #11
    Human Spambot randomuser111's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    2,419

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    Quote Originally Posted by Minion View Post
    I am saying they may not have great picture quality of higher end edge lit model due to absence of local dimming but screen uniformity is much better in back lit models.you will see black in black scenes not gray.
    See this
    LED Backlighting vs. Edgelighting | Home Theater



    You can see advantages of direct lit tvs over edge lit tv when playing a dark scene in both tvs.In tv world what you pay for is what you get.

    One more thing i found is more contrast in led back lit model than old CCFL.

    Sony is selling three types of led tvs they are EX series are edge lit models,HX series are dynamic edge lit models (having local dimming features),HX 925 uses full led with local dimming.

    if you are saying direct lit led is a cheaper tech then why sony HX 925 is using it.
    Did you read my post ? Don't confuse Full Array backlighting WITHOUT Local Dimming and Full Array backlighting WITH Local Dimming. The new cheap Samsung/Sony sets with Direct LED do not have any local dimming so they do not really have great black levels, but yes the only positive is slightly better uniformity.
    HX925 is a Full Array LED Local Dimming set, don't compare it with the cheap Full array sets. Full Array LED with Local Dimming is much more expensive to produce than even EDGE LED. Whereas the Direct LED without local dimming tech use less LEDs than Edge LED and are much cheaper.

    Quote Originally Posted by Kirtu Jindal View Post
    In edge lit LED TVs, the backlight for the LCD screen is provided by LEDS arranged along the edge of the panel. In the full array LED versions, the LEDs are arranged along the whole background of the screen. There is indeed a difference in performance of Edge Lit LED TVs vis-a-vis Full Array LED TVs - mostly in terms of contrast levels and brightness. In full array models, the LEDs in individual segments can be dimmed to create higher contrast. In the same way, since the whole screen background is lit, the brightness is also better. For these two reasons, full array LED TVs are considered to impart a better quality. However, since the number of LEDs needed are many times higher, it invariably leads to significant cost increase - hence this type of TV is more expensive. At present, there are no full array LED TV models in India (of any brand). However, LG is soon expected to introduce LG LM9600 (sometime around Diwali) - this will definitely be the first Full Array LED TV in India.
    A few factual errors in your post (highlighted in bold). Let me correct you

    1. The first Full Array LED TV in India was the Sony X4500 RGB Triluminous LED TV in 2008. Then came the LG B8500 Full Array LED and last year Sony HX925.

    2. There IS a full array LED model on sale currently - Sony Bravia HX925 and by Diwali it will be replaced by HX950 in India.

    3. Quite obviously then, LG LM9600 isn't going to be the first full array set on sale in India. Far from it.

  12. #12
    Wise Old Owl
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Bangalore
    Posts
    1,650

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    Quote Originally Posted by randomuser111 View Post
    Did you read my post ? Don't confuse Full Array backlighting WITHOUT Local Dimming and Full Array backlighting WITH Local Dimming. The new cheap Samsung/Sony sets with Direct LED do not have any local dimming so they do not really have great black levels, but yes the only positive is slightly better uniformity.
    HX925 is a Full Array LED Local Dimming set, don't compare it with the cheap Full array sets. Full Array LED with Local Dimming is much more expensive to produce than even EDGE LED. Whereas the Direct LED without local dimming tech use less LEDs than Edge LED and are much cheaper.
    OMG! This thread is turning into battlefield now.
    Randomuser I know budget samsung/sony set with direct led lit do not have local dimming I am using EH4800 which is a direct led during black scenes it is pure black not grey.If you audition yourself you will know what i am saying.

    I have given example of Sony HX 925 since it is a direct led wiith local dimming i want to convey here, since its a superior tech they are using it in their high end model(not taking local dimming in account)

    In tv world what you pay for is what you get. direct lit budget tv are much better than budget edge lit tvs that is what i want to convey.

  13. #13
    Human Spambot randomuser111's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    2,419

    Default Re: Edge lit LED TV vs. Full array LED

    From CNET

    http://reviews.cnet.com/flat-panel-t...-35159621.html

    Samsung's full-array backlight system uses fewer LEDs than full-array systems on higher-end local-dimming TVs, and fewer even than edge-lit models. The paucity of actual LEDs allows Samsung and other makers of new full-array sets like the EH6000 to charge less than for other kinds of LED TVs

    In picture quality, the EH6000 falls short of many LED and a few non-LED TVs we've tested, displaying a lighter shade of black and poor off-angle viewing.

    The UNEH6000's shade of black was lighter (worse) than that of any other TV in our lineup outside the TCL. In the black areas and letterbox bars of dark scenes, like the Central Park nighttime metal detector hunt from "Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close" (5:50), both of the other Samsung LCDs -- including the edge-lit UND6400 and the CCFL-based LND630 -- were visibly superior, as was the Sharp. The plasmas, as expected, looked better still.


Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •