Proccessor + Mobo within 30k : FX8350 or i5 4670
Menu

digit

 

Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: Proccessor + Mobo within 30k : FX8350 or i5 4670

  1. #1
    Right Off the Assembly Line
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    23

    Lightbulb Proccessor + Mobo within 30k : FX8350 or i5 4670

    Hi guys,

    Please help me finalizing my PC upgrade path. I have been using a rig that has C2D 2GC (E4400) proccesor paired with 2 Gig of ram for about 5 years now. It had a Nvidia 7300GS (512 MB) gfx card. Although it had served me quite well till now, I think the time has come to move on.

    My basic usage - Lots and lots of browsing (most of the times 7,8 windows with 4-8 tabs each) + Occassional 1080p HD vids playback + VM + a very little of software and graphics development. I NEVER have/will play games in my machine.

    I expect my upgrade to stay good for atleast 5~6 years ahead. After this span I will most probably again go for a full upgrade - hence futureproofing is not very critical - as long as it can give me average performance in this period.

    I am slightly inclined towards intel right now because of the below reasons. However I am open for suggestions.

    1. AMD FX 8350 has no integrated graphics ==> I have to buy an extra graphic card.
    Here I assume that if I go for an intel 4th gen i5, the inbuilt graphics will be sufficient for my above requirements. In case this presumption is incorrect, you pros please guide me.

    2. AMD power consumption is greater (My PC will be on for most part of the day)
    The above fact means more heat which enforces the importance of cooling. From reviews, I understand that for getting the best out of fx8350 (i.e performance comparable to 4th G i5) I have to overclock it. Though I am willing to go that way, if I can get equivalent performance without oc at a slight cost premium, I would prefer that. And again overclocking ==> proper cooling system ==> 3-5k extra.

    * - The 'slight' word above can be taken as 3k. If I can overclock 8350 and achieve equivalent performance of i5 and thereby save atleast 3k I will take that route. Or if the difference is going to be less than 3k I will go for intel itself.

    The Intel processor I am considering is i5 - 4670. If I am buying intel I am NOT planning to overclock it. So I presume that stock cooling will be sufficient. My budget for the package is 30K. Budget is not very strict but I am extending it only if it is seriously worth it.


    So long story short,

    AMD ==> Proccy + Mobo + Gfx card + Cooler = 30k,
    INTEL ==> Proccy + Mobo = 30k

    In case I am left with some money I will consider going for i7 - 4770...

    Now dear friends, Let me know that my two presumptions are ok. And also suggest me which path to take. In case I can go for intel, what about H87 chipset ? In particular the ASROCK H87 PRO4 mobo? Will I miss something if I leave out Z87 (because I am finding Z87 costlier than H87 counterparts for no reason??)

    One more small preference I have is atleast 4 usb3 connectors at the rear and 2 at the front (header). Please offer your suggestions. Though I only need suggestions for the key components, I have answered the questionaire to make things clear.



    1. What is the purpose of the computer? What all applications and games are you going to run? (Stupid answers like 'gaming' or 'office work' will not work. Be exact. Which games? Which applications? Avoid the word 'et cetera.')
    Ans: lots of browsing (most of the times 7,8 windows with 4-8 tabs each) + Occassional 1080p HD vids playback + VM + a very little of software and graphics development. I NEVER have/will play games in my machine.

    2. What is your overall budget? If you can extend a bit for a more balanced configuration, then mention this too.
    Ans: 30K (mobo+proccy+gfx)

    3. Planning to overclock?
    Ans: Only if its worth it ( > 3k advantage)

    4. Which Operating System are you planning to use?
    Ans: Linux - flavour keeps changing

    5. How much hard drive space is needed?
    Ans: --

    6. Do you want to buy a monitor? If yes, please mention which screen size and resolution do you want. If you already have a monitor and want to reuse it, again mention the size and resolution of monitor you have.
    Ans: No (Dell 2240L - 22 " 1080p)

    7. Which components you DON'T want to buy or which components you already have and plan on reusing?
    Ans: HDD, Monitor

    8. When are you planning to buy the system?
    Ans: within a month

    9. Have you ever built a desktop before or will this be done by an assembler?
    Ans: have built many. I will be doing this myself.

    10. Where do you live? Are you buying locally? Are you open to buying stuff from online shops if you don't get locally?
    Ans: Blore. Prefer Online shopping.

    11. Anything else which you would like to say?
    Ans: ---


    I already have a seagate barracuda 2TB and dell 2240L to go with my rig. I am expecting a 2x to 4x performance boost to my present config! ( and hopefully I can leave my VM always on..!).

    P.S :
    1. Kindly recommend PSU/Coolers(if reqd) also - outside above 30k.
    2. What I may add in future : an SSD maybe, and a Graphics card (very faint chance)

  2. #2
    laborare est orare Cilus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Kolkata
    Posts
    7,304

    Default Re: Proccessor + Mobo within 30k : FX8350 or i5 4670

    Get FX-8350 @ 12K + Asus M5A99FX EVO 2.0 @ 11K + 8GB 1600 MHz CL9 G-Skill RipjawX @ 4.4K + Gigabyte HD 6670 2GB DDR3 @ 4.6K
    For PSU: Seasonic Eco 500 @ 3.4K
    Cooler: Not needed now if you are not overclocking. Otherwise get something loke Deepcool Assasin @ 3K

    Reasons: -
    1. Better multi-tasking capability.
    2. Overclocking (not possible with i5 4670)
    3. Better virtualization support. AMD FX supports both Vtd abd Vtx.
    4. Very good performance in Linux due to proper OS optimization, just behind i7 3770K
    5. Far cheaper price.
    AMD FX 8350 @ 4.5 GHz|16 GB RipjawX 1873 MHz CL10 @ 1.6V|1+2TB Seagate + 1 TB WD Green 64MB Cache|Sabertooth 990FX|Sapphire HD 7950 VApor-X OC with Boost|GT 240 1 GB GDDR5 PhysX|CM690II Advanced|LG D2342P Cinema 3D Display|TX850 V2|2 CM 1600RPM FAN|MX518|Razer Goliathus|Razer Arctosa|Razer Megalodon 7.1 Headset|CM Hyper 212 Plus|APC1.1KVA| Moto Defy Plus with CM 10.1 JB 4.1|HCL Me Y2 Tab (rooted)] XOLO Q800 with Ultimate V2 JB 4.2.1| Galaxy Tab 2 P3100

  3. #3
    DIY FTW! harshilsharma63's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    Jodhpur
    Posts
    5,598

    Default Re: Proccessor + Mobo within 30k : FX8350 or i5 4670

    Quote Originally Posted by Cilus View Post
    Get FX-8350 @ 12K + Asus M5A99FX EVO 2.0 @ 11K + 8GB 1600 MHz CL9 G-Skill RipjawX @ 4.4K + Gigabyte HD 6670 2GB DDR3 @ 4.6K
    For PSU: Seasonic Eco 500 @ 3.4K
    Cooler: Not needed now if you are not overclocking. Otherwise get something loke Deepcool Assasin @ 3K

    Reasons: -
    1. Better multi-tasking capability.
    2. Overclocking (not possible with i5 4670)
    3. Better virtualization support. AMD FX supports both Vtd abd Vtx.
    4. Very good performance in Linux due to proper OS optimization, just behind i7 3770K
    5. Far cheaper price.
    Seeing OP's post, I dont think he is much into overclocking, and thus no need of such expensive motheroard. I would suggest Asus M5A97 EVO r2.0 available for 7.5k.
    Intel i3 2100 3.1GHz | EVM 2x2 GB DDR3 RAM 1333 MHz | Intel DH61WW | Seagate Barracuda 500 GB | Corsair CX430v2 | Zebronics Oval | LG E2242C 22" FHD | Logitech MK200 | Seagate Extension 500 GB portable HDD | APC RS-600 UPS | Phillips SHP 2000 | Phillips SHE 3590PP | Nokia X2-00

    There is only one success - self satisfaction.

  4. #4
    Right Off the Assembly Line
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    23

    Default Re: Proccessor + Mobo within 30k : FX8350 or i5 4670

    Thank you cilus & harshil.

    Btw, was the choice this much evident to just go for AMD and drop intel? (Then why was I so confused! )
    And with this config, how will the performance be with/without OC? if OC will give significant advantage, I will go for a better mobo with cooler? what do you suggest guys?

    And cilus, you referring to Asus M5A99FX Pro R2.0 or Asus M5A99X Evo R2.0 ?? And sadly all three mainboards have only 2 usb3 ports in the back panel...

  5. #5
    laborare est orare Cilus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Kolkata
    Posts
    7,304

    Default Re: Proccessor + Mobo within 30k : FX8350 or i5 4670

    Buddy, if gaming was in your preference list, i5 4670 could have been suggested but for your requirements FX-8350 is a better choice and the reasons I have put in my earlier post. The stock performance of FX-8350 is pretty good and ahead of 4670 in most cases, specially in Linux and obviously a 400 to 500 MHz Overclocking will give you good performance boost. The motherboard I was suggesting is the M5A99FX one, not the 99X one. The former one is based on AMD 990FX chipset whereas the later one is based on 990X chipset. Regarding USB 3.0 ports, even the costlier Sabertooth 990FX provides only two back USB 3 ports. But it comes with two USB 3.0 header which can be used to get another 4 USB 3.0 ports using uSB 3.0 brackets.
    AMD FX 8350 @ 4.5 GHz|16 GB RipjawX 1873 MHz CL10 @ 1.6V|1+2TB Seagate + 1 TB WD Green 64MB Cache|Sabertooth 990FX|Sapphire HD 7950 VApor-X OC with Boost|GT 240 1 GB GDDR5 PhysX|CM690II Advanced|LG D2342P Cinema 3D Display|TX850 V2|2 CM 1600RPM FAN|MX518|Razer Goliathus|Razer Arctosa|Razer Megalodon 7.1 Headset|CM Hyper 212 Plus|APC1.1KVA| Moto Defy Plus with CM 10.1 JB 4.1|HCL Me Y2 Tab (rooted)] XOLO Q800 with Ultimate V2 JB 4.2.1| Galaxy Tab 2 P3100

  6. #6
    Right Off the Assembly Line
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    23

    Default Re: Proccessor + Mobo within 30k : FX8350 or i5 4670

    Hmm... Seems I have to compromise with my USB3 ports...
    Thank you guys..

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •